Why the British Cannot Decide How They Feel About the Monarchy

On the great national ambivalence at the heart of our constitutional arrangement

The British relationship with the monarchy is one of the most complicated in any national psychology, a tangle of affection, resentment, pride, embarrassment, loyalty, and mockery that resolves into no clear position whatsoever. We cannot decide how we feel, and I have come to believe that this very indecision is the secret of the institution survival.

The Affectionate Mockery

The British do not revere their monarchy in the way some imagine. We mock it constantly, mercilessly, in our newspapers and our comedy and our pubs. And yet the mockery is rarely hostile. It is the mockery one reserves for family, affectionate even at its sharpest, a sign of intimacy rather than contempt. We feel entitled to laugh at the Royal Family precisely because, in some strange way, we feel they are ours.

This is a subtle thing, difficult to explain to those from republics or absolute monarchies alike. We are neither worshipful nor revolutionary. We are something stranger, a nation that holds its monarchy in a permanent state of fond exasperation, like a relative we would never disown but would also never fully defend.

The Republican Question

There is, of course, a serious republican case, and it deserves a fair hearing. Those who argue against the monarchy point to the principle of equality, the absurdity of hereditary privilege, the cost, the deference it demands. These are not foolish arguments, and the debate over the institution future is a legitimate one that periodically surfaces in our national life. I do not dismiss it.

And yet the republican movement, for all the strength of its arguments, has never quite captured the national imagination, and I think this is because it asks the British to resolve an ambivalence we rather enjoy. To become a republic would be to decide, finally, how we feel, and deciding is precisely what we have so artfully avoided for centuries.

The Uses of Continuity

The strongest argument for the monarchy, to my mind, is not about any individual royal but about continuity, the sense of a thread running through national life, connecting present to past. In a world of dizzying change, there is something steadying about an institution that has endured for a thousand years, that links us to our history in a way no elected official ever could. The preservation of this heritage is documented by various royal and historical bodies.

Whether that steadiness is worth the price, in money and principle and democratic logic, is a fair question. But it is not nothing, this continuity, and those who would sweep the monarchy away should reckon honestly with what would be lost, as well as what would be gained. The thread, once cut, cannot be retied.

Living with Ambivalence

I do not expect the British to resolve their feelings about the monarchy any time soon, and on the whole I am glad of it. There is wisdom in our ambivalence, a refusal to be forced into a simple position on a complicated thing. We will go on loving and mocking, defending and deriding, our peculiar institution, and the institution will go on enduring, sustained as much by our indecision as by our devotion.

It is not a logical arrangement. It would not be designed this way by any rational constitutional architect. But it is ours, this muddle, this fond exasperation, this crown held perpetually at arms length and never quite let go. And there is, I have decided, something rather British and rather wonderful in that.

What I Tell the Republicans, and What I Tell the Royalists

I occupy an awkward position, writing about the monarchy with neither the fervour of the royalist nor the conviction of the republican, and both camps find me frustrating. To the republicans, who make their excellent arguments about equality and hereditary privilege and cost, I say: you are right about almost everything, and you will still lose, because you are arguing with logic against something that does not run on logic. To the royalists, who speak of continuity and tradition and the magic of the crown, I say: you are right about the feeling, and you should be honest that it is a feeling, not an argument, and that feelings, however powerful, are a precarious foundation for a constitutional settlement. Neither answer satisfies. The republicans want me to commit to the revolution. The royalists want me to kneel. And I do neither, because the truth, as I see it, is that the British monarchy survives precisely in the space between these positions, in the great national ambivalence that refuses to resolve, and that to pick a side cleanly would be to misunderstand the strange and muddled thing that the monarchy actually is. I am, I suppose, a connoisseur of the muddle, and the muddle is where I have made my home.

And so I remain in the muddle, the connoisseur of the unresolved, watching both camps make their cases and finding, in the very irresolution of the national feeling, something worth defending. The ambivalence is not a failure to think clearly. It is, I have come to believe, a kind of wisdom, a refusal to flatten a complicated thing into a simple slogan, and I would not trade it for the false clarity of either certainty.

Further reading: the official Royal Family site, the Royal Collection Trust, Historic Royal Palaces.

SOURCE: https://prat.uk/

For more satire, see NewsThump.