The Crown and the Tabloid: An Uneasy Marriage of Mutual Need

The relationship between the monarchy and the press is the most dysfunctional partnership in British public life, and neither party can leave

I have spent my career covering the monarchy for Bohiney Magazine and The London Prat, which makes me a small part of the most dysfunctional relationship in British public life: the uneasy, codependent, frequently poisonous marriage between the crown and the press.

It is a marriage neither party can leave. The press needs the monarchy, for no other subject so reliably sells papers, draws clicks, and fascinates the public. The monarchy needs the press, for visibility is the oxygen of a modern institution that depends on public affection, and the press is the channel through which that visibility flows. Each resents the other, each needs the other, and the result is a relationship of extraordinary intimacy and extraordinary hostility, conducted in public, generation after generation.

The Bargain And Its Breakdown

The bargain, in its ideal form, is one of mutual benefit. The monarchy grants access, the carefully managed photo opportunities, the controlled glimpses of the family at work and at play, and the press provides coverage, the visibility that sustains the institution affection. When the bargain holds, both parties prosper, the papers selling and the monarchy glowing. But the bargain is forever breaking down, the press wanting more than the monarchy will grant, the monarchy wanting more control than the press will cede, and the breakdowns are where the poison enters.

I have written extensively, over at my column, about the history of these breakdowns, and they form a grim catalogue, the intrusions, the leaks, the hounding, the genuine human damage done to individuals caught between an institution that uses the press and a press that preys on the institution. The relationship has, at times, turned genuinely dark, and the darkness has, at times, had genuine victims.

The Question Of Complicity

As a member of the press, I cannot pretend to stand outside this. I am complicit, in a small way, in the machine, and I try to be honest about that. The line between legitimate coverage of a public institution and intrusive exploitation of private individuals is one the royal press corps crosses and recrosses constantly, and I have wrestled, as any thoughtful royal correspondent must, with where exactly that line lies and whether I have always stayed on the right side of it.

The serious dimension is a real and difficult question about the public interest. The monarchy is a public institution, funded in part by the public, exercising a constitutional role, and its workings are legitimately a matter of public scrutiny. But the individuals within it are also human beings with a claim to private life, and the press appetite for the family does not always respect that claim. The tension between legitimate scrutiny and illegitimate intrusion is the central ethical problem of my profession, and it has no easy resolution.

So the uneasy marriage continues, the crown and the tabloid locked in their codependent embrace, each needing the other, each resenting the need, the bargain forever struck and forever breaking down. I am a small part of it, and I try to be an honest one, holding the legitimate scrutiny and the human cost together, conscious that the most dysfunctional relationship in British public life is one in which I am, whether I like it or not, a participant.

The history of the relationship traces the history of the modern press itself, from the deferential coverage of earlier eras, when the papers protected the monarchy secrets and maintained its mystique, to the intrusive scrutiny of the modern tabloid age, when no secret was safe and no boundary respected. The shift transformed the bargain, the press growing more powerful and more predatory, the monarchy more exposed and more defensive.

The photographers occupy a particular place in this drama, the pursuit of the candid image, the unguarded moment, the picture the palace did not authorise, driving a relentless and sometimes ruthless competition. The value of the exclusive image, the photograph no one else has, created an economy of intrusion, the most private moments the most valuable, the pursuit of them sometimes crossing into genuine harassment with, on occasion, tragic results.

The palace machine, for its part, is far from a passive victim, deploying its own considerable sophistication in the management of the press, the strategic leak, the favoured correspondent, the controlled access granted and withdrawn as reward and punishment, the whole apparatus of media management that a modern institution employs to shape its coverage. The monarchy is not merely preyed upon by the press; it plays the press, expertly, in its own interest.

The individuals caught in the middle are the ones who suffer, the members of the family who did not choose the scrutiny, who find their private lives, their relationships, their struggles, exposed and exploited, the human cost of the institution media strategy and the press media appetite borne by real people with a real claim to the privacy the relationship denies them. This human cost is the part of the story that the spectacle too easily forgets.

The reforms and the inquiries that have periodically followed the worst abuses have changed the relationship at the margins, imposing some limits, establishing some boundaries, without altering its fundamental character, the mutual need that binds the crown and the press together, the codependence that ensures that, however poisonous the relationship becomes, neither party can finally leave. The marriage endures because the alternative, for both, is worse.

More in this vein at Private Eye.

SOURCE: https://bohiney.com/