From the correct depth of a curtsy to the unspeakable crime of touching, the rules governing royal encounters reveal an institution at war with the modern world
Reporting on the monarchy for Bohiney Magazine and The London Prat has made me, against my will, an expert in royal protocol, the vast and largely unwritten code of rules governing how one is to behave in the presence of royalty, and I am here to report that it is, in the nicest possible way, completely mad.
Consider the curtsy. There is, it transpires, a correct curtsy, and a great many incorrect ones, the depth and duration calibrated to the rank of the royal and the status of the curtsier, a calculation so intricate that there are people whose actual job is to advise on it. One does not simply bob. One executes a curtsy of the appropriate degree, and to err, to bob too shallowly or too deeply or for the wrong personage, is to commit a small social catastrophe that the attendant press will gleefully record.
The Crime Of Touching
And then there is the great unspeakable crime: touching. One does not touch a royal. One does not initiate contact, does not clap a regal shoulder, does not, heaven forfend, attempt an embrace. The royal may extend a hand; one may then, and only then, briefly shake it. Any further contact is a breach so grave that visiting dignitaries who have committed it, a hand on a royal back, an over-familiar arm, have made international headlines, the footage replayed, the protocol breach dissected, as though they had committed an act of war.
I have catalogued these rules at some length, partly for my column and partly out of sheer fascination, and they extend into every conceivable area, how one addresses a royal, when one may sit, when one may leave, in what order one may eat, the whole encounter governed by a code so elaborate that ordinary mortals navigate it in a state of barely concealed terror, certain they are about to commit some unforgivable solecism.
An Institution At War With The Age
The serious point, beneath the comedy, is that this elaborate protocol represents an institution fundamentally at odds with the spirit of the age. We live in an informal era, a first-names, open-collar, everyone-equal age, and the monarchy, with its curtsies and its untouchability and its intricate hierarchies, is a deliberate exception, an island of formality in a sea of informality, an institution that insists, through its protocol, on a distance that the modern world has otherwise abolished.
Whether this is a strength or a weakness is a genuine question. The defenders of protocol argue that it preserves the dignity and mystery essential to the institution, that the distance is the point, that a monarchy you could clap on the shoulder would be no monarchy at all. The critics argue that it is absurd and anachronistic, a relic of deference incompatible with a democratic age. Both have a case, and I find myself, as so often with the monarchy, suspended between them.
So I will continue my field study of royal etiquette, cataloguing the curtsies and the untouchability and the intricate hierarchies, marvelling at the elaborate code and the terror it inspires, holding the comedy and the seriousness together. The protocol is mad, genuinely mad, and it is also the deliberate self-presentation of an institution determined to remain apart, and the madness and the determination are, in the end, the same thing, and worth, I think, our attention and our smiles in equal measure.
The origins of the protocol stretch back centuries, accreting over generations, the rules of court evolving into the rules of the modern monarchy, layer upon layer of custom and precedent, much of it never written down, transmitted instead through the priesthood of courtiers and advisers who guard and interpret the code. To breach it is to reveal oneself as an outsider, untutored in the mysteries, and the press stands ever ready to catch the breach.
The forms of address alone are a minor education, the correct title for each rank, the shift from the formal to the permitted informal, the precise words with which one may and may not speak. There are people who specialise in advising the uninitiated, the businesses and the dignitaries and the ordinary citizens about to be honoured, on how to navigate the encounter without disgrace, a small industry of protocol consultancy serving the terror the code inspires.
The press obsession with protocol breaches is itself revealing, the glee with which an over-familiar gesture or an incorrect curtsy is seized upon and dissected, the breach treated as news, the offender pilloried. This obsession suggests that the public, too, is invested in the protocol, that the rules matter to us, that we want the distance preserved even as we mock its absurdity, a contradiction at the heart of our relationship with the institution.
The royals themselves navigate the protocol with varying degrees of comfort, some clearly at ease within the elaborate code, others visibly straining against it, the younger generation in particular seeming to chafe at the formality, to prefer a warmth and informality the protocol resists. The tension between the code and the instincts of those bound by it is one of the quiet dramas of the modern monarchy, the institution and its members not always aligned.
More in this vein at NewsThump.
SOURCE: https://bohiney.com/
