Setting aside both the reflexive deference and the reflexive contempt, what is the real case for and against the crown in a democratic age?
I have spent these dispatches, written for Bohiney Magazine and The London Prat, exploring the fascination, the theatre, the protocol, and the press relationship of the monarchy, mostly with affection and amusement. But I would be a poor correspondent if I never confronted the serious question that hangs over all of it: does the monarchy have a future, and should it?
This is the republican question, and it deserves to be addressed honestly, setting aside both the reflexive deference that treats the monarchy as beyond criticism and the reflexive contempt that treats it as self-evidently absurd. There is a real case on each side, and a thoughtful citizen, whatever their conclusion, owes both cases a fair hearing. Let me try to give them one.
The Case For The Crown
The case for the monarchy rests on several genuine arguments. It provides a head of state above politics, a focus of national unity untainted by partisan division, a ceremonial figure who can represent the whole nation in a way no elected politician, owing their position to one faction, ever could. It provides continuity, a living link to history, a stability that the churn of democratic politics lacks. And it provides, its defenders argue, a soft power and a national distinctiveness of real, if intangible, value. These are not foolish arguments, and I have laid them out fairly in my column.
There is also the practical argument, that the monarchy works, that the British constitutional arrangement, whatever its theoretical oddities, has produced stable democratic government for a very long time, and that the wise course is not to dismantle a functioning system in pursuit of theoretical purity. The conservative case for the monarchy is, at bottom, a case against the risks of change, a preference for the tested over the untried.
The Case Against
The case against the monarchy is equally serious. There is the principled objection, that hereditary privilege is fundamentally incompatible with democratic equality, that a position of such symbolic importance should not be allocated by birth, that no one should be born to reign over others. There is the objection of cost, the expense of the institution in an age of austerity. And there is the human objection, that the institution inflicts a genuine cost on the individuals trapped within it, demanding a sacrifice of privacy and autonomy that no one should be born into.
These are weighty arguments, and the republican who makes them is not, whatever the deferential might suggest, a crank or a vandal, but a citizen taking seriously the principle of democratic equality. The monarchy, on this view, is a beautiful anachronism whose time has passed, a relic of deference that a mature democracy should, gently and with gratitude for its service, retire.
Where do I land? I will not tell you, for it is not my place, as a correspondent, to instruct you how to vote on the constitution of your own country, and the honest answer is that I find myself genuinely torn, drawn to the arguments on both sides, unresolved as I am about so much of the institution I cover. What I will say is that the question deserves a serious and honest debate, free of both deference and contempt, and that a nation confident enough to ask it openly is a nation in good democratic health, whatever answer it eventually gives.
The republican question has a long history in Britain, periodically rising and falling, the subject of serious debate in some eras and quiet dormancy in others, the strength of the republican case waxing and waning with the popularity of the particular individuals occupying the throne, the institution fortunes tied, perhaps more than its defenders would like, to the personal qualities of its current representatives.
The comparison with other constitutional monarchies is instructive, the various European kingdoms that have retained their crowns while modernising them, slimming them down, reducing their cost and their pomp, integrating them more comfortably into democratic life. These examples suggest a middle path between abolition and the status quo, a reformed and modernised monarchy that might address some of the republican objections without the upheaval of abolition.
The comparison with republics is equally instructive, the various ways that nations without monarchies provide a head of state, the ceremonial presidents who perform the unifying function, the elected figures who represent the nation above politics. These examples suggest that the functions the monarchy performs can be performed otherwise, that the choice is not between the monarchy and chaos but between different ways of providing a head of state, each with its own advantages and costs.
The cost question, often raised, is more complicated than either side admits, the expense of the institution real but modest in the context of national budgets, the economic benefits claimed by its defenders, the tourism, the soft power, genuine but difficult to quantify. The honest accounting is murkier than the partisans on either side suggest, the monarchy neither the ruinous extravagance its critics claim nor the self-funding asset its defenders assert.
The human dimension, the cost to the individuals within the institution, has become more prominent in recent debates, the recognition that the demands placed on those born into the family, the loss of privacy, the constraint of autonomy, the relentless scrutiny, constitute a genuine burden that the institution imposes on real people. This argument cuts in complex ways, raising questions about consent, about duty, about the ethics of an institution that binds the unborn to roles they did not choose.
More in this vein at The Daily Mash.
SOURCE: https://bohiney.com/
