The Strange National Sport of Royal-Watching, and Why We Cannot Look Away

A correspondent’s reflections on the peculiar British compulsion to scrutinise a family we will never meet and cannot quite explain

I cover the monarchy for Bohiney Magazine and The London Prat, which means I am a professional royal-watcher, a phrase that still strikes me, after all these years, as faintly absurd, as though I were paid to study a particularly elaborate species of swan.

And yet here I am, having built a career on the observation of a single family, their comings and goings, their hats and their feuds, their weddings and their funerals, their every gesture parsed for meaning by a press corps of which I am, I must confess, a willing member. It is a strange way to make a living, and the British compulsion that sustains it is stranger still, a national obsession with a family we will never meet and cannot quite explain.

The Soap Opera With A Constitution

What is it, exactly, that we are watching? Partly it is a soap opera, the longest-running and best-funded in the world, with a cast of characters we have followed for generations, their dramas more compelling for being real, or at least as real as anything filtered through the palace press machine ever is. We watch them as we watch any long-running drama, invested in the characters, alert to the plot twists, mourning the departures and celebrating the arrivals.

But it is also, of course, a constitutional arrangement, a head of state who reigns but does not rule, a living link to a thousand years of history, a focus of national identity and continuity in a country that has lost so much else. The serious analysis of the monarchy constitutional role, which I have written about at length over at my column, treats it as a matter of governance and tradition, and so it is. But the constitutional dimension does not explain the obsession. No one is obsessed with the constitution.

The Family We Have Chosen

The obsession, I have come to think, is something more primal, a need for a family at the centre of the national life, a cast of characters who belong to all of us, whose dramas we can follow and whose milestones we can share. The Royal Family is, in this sense, the family we have collectively chosen, or perhaps inherited, a shared point of reference in a fragmented age, a soap opera we are all, whether we admit it or not, watching together.

I am aware, as I write this, of the criticisms, and they are serious ones. The expense, the inequality, the strangeness of hereditary privilege in a democratic age, the human cost to the individuals trapped inside the institution. These are real arguments, and I will return to them, for a thoughtful royal-watcher must hold the fascination and the critique together. But today I am simply confessing the fascination, the strange compulsion that I share with millions, to watch this family we will never meet.

So I will keep watching, keep parsing the hats and the gestures, keep covering the swan, because it is my job and because, beneath the job, I am as caught as anyone in the strange national sport of royal-watching. We cannot look away. We have tried, periodically, as a nation, and we have failed, and the failure is itself the most interesting thing about us, the clue to something we have not quite worked out about ourselves.

The history of royal-watching is older than the tabloids, older than photography, older than the modern press, for there has always been a public appetite for the doings of the crown, a fascination with the lives of those at the apex of the social order. What has changed is the intensity and the intimacy, the modern media bringing the family into our homes, onto our screens, into our daily conversation, in a way that earlier ages could not have imagined.

The press relationship with the monarchy is a complex and often uncomfortable one, the palace and the papers locked in a mutual dependence, each needing the other, each resenting the need. The papers need the family for the readers it draws; the family needs the papers for the visibility that sustains its relevance. The result is an uneasy dance of access and intrusion, cooperation and conflict, that I have observed from the inside for years.

The individuals caught inside the institution deserve more sympathy than the obsession usually grants them, for they did not, most of them, choose the roles they were born into, the relentless scrutiny, the loss of privacy, the strange half-life of being public property. The human cost of the institution falls on real people, and the royal-watcher who forgets this, who treats the family as mere spectacle, has lost something important.

The constitutional function, meanwhile, proceeds quietly beneath the spectacle, the head of state performing the ceremonial duties, the opening of parliaments, the receiving of ambassadors, the small constitutional rituals that, in the British arrangement, the monarch performs so that the politicians need not, a separation of the dignified from the efficient that has its defenders and its critics and that I find genuinely interesting as a matter of governance.

The obsession and the constitution, the spectacle and the governance, the soap opera and the head of state, coexist in the strange institution of the British monarchy, and the royal-watcher who would understand it must hold all of these together, the fascination and the critique, the human cost and the constitutional function, the family we have chosen and the privilege we have inherited. It is a tangle, and the tangle is the point.

More in this vein at Private Eye.

SOURCE: https://bohiney.com/