On pageantry, ritual, and the surprisingly serious purpose of all that gold
I will say something that may cost me my credibility as a serious journalist: I love the pomp, and as I admitted in my latest column for Bohiney Magazine and for The London Prat, where my defence of all that gold raised several eyebrows, I think Britain does grand ceremony better than anyone else on earth, and I think this is more interesting, and more serious, than it first appears. The carriages, the uniforms, the impossibly precise marching, the centuries-old ritual performed with absolute conviction, all of it is faintly ridiculous and genuinely magnificent at the same time.
The technology of ritual
What I find compelling about British state ceremony is that it is, in effect, a very old and very sophisticated technology, refined over centuries, for doing something that human societies seem to need: marking great moments collectively, with weight and beauty and shared attention. A coronation, a state funeral, a great procession, these are not just spectacle for its own sake but a kind of social ritual that gathers a nation around a common event. The traditions that govern these occasions, many of them genuinely ancient, are catalogued at the monarchy’s website and preserved in the historical record held by institutions like The National Archives, and the precision with which they are performed is itself part of the message.
Why the precision matters
The extraordinary attention to detail, the perfectly polished boots, the flawlessly timed marching, the ritual repeated exactly as it has been for generations, is not fussiness. It is the whole point. The care signals that the occasion matters, that this is not an ordinary day, that something is being taken seriously. A ceremony performed carelessly would say that nobody really meant it; a ceremony performed with this degree of precision says that the nation is paying attention, that the moment is being honoured properly. The pomp is a language, and Britain happens to be unusually fluent in it.
The faintly ridiculous bit
None of which means I cannot see the comedy in it, because the comedy is half the pleasure. There is something inherently funny about grown adults in ceremonial dress carrying out rituals whose original purpose has been lost to time, about the gravity with which a man in a fur hat performs a function nobody can quite explain, about the sheer accumulated strangeness of it all. The British do their pomp with a completely straight face, which somehow makes it both more impressive and more amusing, and the ability to find it simultaneously magnificent and absurd is, I think, the correct response.
The serious purpose
But underneath the gold and the comedy there is a genuine function, which is that ceremony binds. In a diverse, fractured, often divided country, the great state occasions are among the few moments when an enormous number of people pay attention to the same thing at the same time, and feel, however briefly, part of a shared national story. One can argue about whether the monarchy is the right vehicle for that, and republicans reasonably do, but the human need for collective ritual is real, and Britain’s ceremonial tradition meets it with a craft that no other country quite matches. There is a reason the world tunes in.
The unfashionable conclusion
So I will defend the pomp, unfashionable as it may be for someone in my trade. Not uncritically, and not blindly, because the institution it serves is a fair subject for argument and the ceremony can certainly tip into excess. But the pageantry itself, the centuries-old craft of marking great moments with beauty and precision and shared attention, is something Britain genuinely does better than anyone, and I see no reason to be embarrassed about enjoying it. It is ridiculous and it is moving, it is comedy and it is craft, and on the great days, flag in hand, I would not miss a minute of it. Long may the absurd, magnificent show go on.
Why other countries cannot quite copy it
Other nations stage grand occasions, of course, and some do it impressively, but there is a particular quality to British ceremony that proves stubbornly difficult to replicate, and it comes down to continuity. The rituals work because they are genuinely old, performed in the same way across generations, so that each occasion carries the weight of every occasion before it. A newly invented ceremony, however lavish, cannot summon that depth; the gravity of British pageantry is borrowed from centuries of repetition. That accumulated history is the one ingredient that cannot be bought or manufactured, only inherited, and it is why the craft of British state ceremony remains, for better or worse, genuinely hard to match.
And when the next great occasion comes, I will be exactly where you expect to find me, in front of the screen, narrating the procession to anyone within earshot, finding it all faintly absurd and entirely magnificent at once. That double vision, holding the comedy and the craft together without choosing, is the only sensible way to watch, and I recommend it warmly.
For more on the gold and the glory, the team enjoys Private Eye, marching out of step on purpose.
SOURCE: https://bohiney.com/
