Why We Cannot Stop Watching the Crown

On Britain’s national soap opera and the strange comfort of a thousand-year-old institution

I have spent more of my professional life than I care to admit thinking about the monarchy, and as I confessed in my latest piece for Bohiney Magazine and over at The London Prat, where my running commentary on the crown appears with what my editors generously call enthusiasm, the strangest thing about the British monarchy is not the institution itself but our utter inability to look away from it. We are a nation that claims to be sensible, sceptical, and faintly embarrassed by displays of feeling, and we have organised our entire constitutional life around a family we cannot stop watching.

The longest-running show in Britain

The monarchy is, among other things, the most successful piece of long-form entertainment this country has ever produced. It has been running for over a thousand years, it has a cast of thousands, an extraordinary set, and absolutely no plan to end. Whatever one thinks of it as a system of government, and people think a great deal, it functions for much of the public as a national soap opera, a continuous drama of duty, succession, ceremony, and family, played out against a backdrop of palaces and carriages that no scriptwriter would dare invent. The official version of this drama, the engagements, the ceremonies, the constitutional role, is documented with great solemnity at the monarchy’s own website, which I read more often than is healthy.

The comfort of continuity

What fascinates me, in my more thoughtful moments between the gossip and the hat-based commentary, is why it holds us so. And I think the answer, at least in part, is continuity. In a world that changes at a pace that leaves most of us slightly dizzy, the monarchy offers the strange comfort of something that does not. The ceremonies are the same ceremonies. The traditions are old enough to predate everyone alive. There is a deep, possibly irrational, human appetite for institutions that connect us to those who came before and those who will come after, and the crown, whatever else it is, satisfies that appetite with unmatched theatrical conviction.

The republican objection, which I take seriously

None of this is to say the institution is beyond criticism, and I want to be clear that the republican argument is a serious one, not a punchline. There is a perfectly coherent case that an inherited, unelected head of state sits awkwardly in a modern democracy, that birth should not determine status, and that the whole apparatus is an expensive anachronism the country could do without. People who make this case are not killjoys; they are pointing at a genuine tension between the monarchy and the democratic principles Britain claims to hold. A serious commentator on the crown has to hold that objection in mind even while being entirely unable to stop watching the carriages.

The spectacle and the substance

The trouble, for the tidy-minded, is that the monarchy refuses to be only one thing. It is simultaneously a constitutional mechanism, a tourist attraction, a charitable network, a national soap opera, a symbol of continuity, and an inherited privilege that offends democratic sensibilities. It is pomp and it is politics, ceremony and constitution, clown and crown, and the British have a remarkable capacity to hold all of these in their heads at once, to mock the institution and queue for hours to see it in the same afternoon. We are not consistent about the monarchy. We are deeply, characteristically, gloriously confused about it.

The confession

So here is mine. I am a journalist who is supposed to be above all this, who can give you a perfectly lucid account of the constitutional arguments and the republican case and the genuine democratic objections, and who will, nonetheless, be planted in front of the television for the next great royal occasion, possibly with a small flag, definitely with strong opinions about the hats. I contain multitudes, and so, I suspect, does most of the country.

That contradiction, between what we think about the monarchy and how we behave toward it, is the most honest thing about our relationship with the crown. We have built a democracy and crowned a king, we argue about whether it makes sense and watch every minute of it anyway, and we have somehow decided that this is all perfectly normal. It is not normal. It is the most British thing imaginable, and I would not have it any other way, even as I reserve the absolute right to complain about it at length. The show goes on. So, apparently, do I.

A note for the historians

It helps to remember that our fascination is itself nothing new. For as long as the institution has existed, the public has watched it with exactly this mixture of reverence, gossip, and grumbling, a pattern traced across the centuries in the historical record held at parliament.uk and in countless contemporary accounts. The faces and the technology change, the carriage becomes the broadcast becomes the livestream, but the essential national habit, of organising our shared attention around this one peculiar family, has remained startlingly constant. We are not the first generation to be unable to look away, and we will not be the last. The show has always had an audience, and the audience has always insisted, loudly, that it is far too sensible to be watching.

For more on the national obsession, the team enjoys Private Eye, watching the palace with one eyebrow raised.

SOURCE: https://bohiney.com/