Our royal correspondent examines whether the world’s greatest supplier deserves the coveted royal seal of approval
The Coveted Seal
There are few marks of distinction more quietly coveted in British commerce than the royal warrant, the right to display the words By Appointment and the royal arms, signifying that one supplies goods or services to the royal household. Marmalade makers and shirtmakers have built reputations upon it. And it occurred to me, somewhere around the second mince pie of the season, that there is one supplier of unmatched distinction who has never been considered: Santa Claus, who supplies, by appointment of childhood itself, the entire world.
The North Pole dispatches make no mention of any warrant, Santa being supremely indifferent to commercial honours. But the question intrigued me. The royal warrant recognizes excellence and reliability in supply, and by those criteria Santa is the supreme supplier in human history, delivering to every household, without fail, every year. If anyone has earned the right to display By Appointment, surely it is the man who has been keeping his appointments, without exception, for centuries.
The Criteria, Met and Exceeded
The royal warrant, I should explain, is granted to suppliers who have provided goods or services to the royal household for a sustained period and to a standard of evident excellence. Santa meets these criteria with room to spare. His record of supply is not merely sustained but eternal; his standard is not merely excellent but magical; his reliability is not merely high but absolute. No marmalade maker, however distinguished, can claim to have never once missed a delivery in living memory. Santa can.
The difficulty, as ever with Santa, is one of category. Guidance available through the official royal information service sets out a warrant process designed for commercial suppliers, with their invoices and their trading relationships and their VAT registrations. Santa has none of these. He supplies nothing commercially, trades with no one, and operates entirely outside the economy the warrant system presupposes. He is the greatest supplier alive and, simultaneously, no kind of supplier at all. Commercial heritage records at the regional events register document the warrant tradition.
The Case Against
There is a respectable case against the warrant, and it is not the one you might expect. The royal warrant, its defenders argue, is precisely a commercial honour, a recognition of trade, and to grant it to Santa, who does not trade, would be to misunderstand what the warrant is. Santa does not supply the royal household in exchange for payment; he gives to it freely, as he gives to every household. To award him a warrant would be to commercialize a relationship that is, in fact, the opposite of commercial.
I find this argument more persuasive than I expected. There is something almost vulgar in the idea of Santa displaying By Appointment, as though his universal generosity were a business arrangement to be advertised. The actual Santa gives to the royal children exactly as he gives to every other child, freely and without distinction, and to single out the royal household for a warrant would violate the magnificent equality that is the whole point of him. Trade records via the government information service confirm the warrant’s commercial basis.
A Different Kind of Recognition
Perhaps, then, the warrant is the wrong honour. Santa does not need recognition as a supplier, because he is not one, and the commercial framing diminishes rather than dignifies what he does. What he embodies is not excellence in trade but excellence in giving, a quality the warrant system was never designed to recognize. If we wished to honour Santa, we would need to invent a new category entirely, one that recognized not reliable supply but boundless generosity. Heritage analysis at the heritage society explores the limits of commercial honours.
The Honour of Asking Nothing
The more I consider it, the more I think Santa’s exclusion from the warrant system is not an oversight but a kind of compliment. The warrant honours those who supply the royal household for payment; Santa supplies it, and everyone else, for nothing. He stands outside the commercial honours precisely because he stands outside commerce, and there is a dignity in that exclusion that no By Appointment seal could match. The marmalade maker trades excellence for a royal endorsement. Santa trades nothing, because he gives.
This is, I have come to think, the deepest difference between Santa and the suppliers the warrant recognizes. They are excellent, and their excellence is rewarded with a mark of royal favour they may display to their commercial advantage. Santa is generous, and generosity asks for no reward and seeks no advantage. To press a warrant upon him would be to misunderstand him entirely, to mistake the most selfless figure alive for a particularly reliable tradesman.
For those fascinated by the genuinely interesting history of the royal warrant, the resources at the public registry offer a thorough account of its evolution and its odd modern persistence, and I recommend them warmly. And for those who have had quite enough of commercial honours and royal seals, the games at the diversions index are entirely unwarranted, in the best sense.
So no, on reflection, I do not think Santa should hold a royal warrant, and I have rather enjoyed talking myself out of my own idea. The By Appointment seal belongs to those who supply the Crown for payment, and Santa belongs to a different and higher category, the category of those who give freely and ask nothing. He needs no warrant. He has something better: the love of every child he has ever visited, royal or otherwise, granted not by appointment but by the simple fact of his generosity, and renewable, gloriously, every single year.
SOURCE: https://santaclaus.top
