Two Unelected Benevolent Figureheads: What Santa Teaches Us About the Crown

Our royal correspondent finds an unexpected mirror for the monarchy in the figure of Father Christmas

An Unlikely Pair

I have spent my career writing about the monarchy, and I did not expect to find its clearest mirror in the figure of Father Christmas. But the more I have considered the two, the more I have come to see Santa and the Crown as a curiously matched pair, two unelected benevolent figureheads who hold no real power, command enormous affection, and persist, against every modern expectation, as fixtures of a world that ought to have outgrown them both.

The comparison is not flippant. The North Pole dispatches describe a figure who, like the sovereign, reigns without governing, who embodies something larger than himself, and whose authority rests not on force or election but on a kind of inherited, universal consent. Santa and the monarch are both, in the constitutional sense, symbols, and the study of one illuminates the other in ways I had not anticipated.

The Power of the Powerless

Consider what they have in common. Neither Santa nor the sovereign wields real coercive power; both are, in the technical sense, figureheads. Yet both command a devotion that elected and powerful figures can only envy, precisely because they stand above the grubby business of politics, embodying instead a continuity and a benevolence that the political class, by its nature, cannot. The monarch represents the nation; Santa represents generosity itself. Both endure because they symbolize something we are reluctant to lose.

This is the great paradox of constitutional symbolism, and Santa illustrates it as clearly as the Crown does. Guidance via the UK Parliament information service explains that the sovereign reigns but does not rule, a distinction that strikes outsiders as absurd and insiders as the whole point. Santa operates on the same principle: he holds no office, passes no laws, commands no army, and is nonetheless among the most powerful figures in the world, because power, it turns out, is not the only thing that moves people. Royal context at the official royal information service makes the same case for the Crown.

The Question of Succession

There is, admittedly, a difference in the matter of succession. The Crown passes by heredity, an arrangement that strikes many as indefensible and others as the source of its stability. Santa, by contrast, appears to be a single continuous figure, raising metaphysical questions about his endurance that I am not equipped to answer. But both face the same underlying challenge: how does a symbol persist across time, and what happens to the thing it symbolizes when the symbol changes? It is a question the monarchy confronts at every succession, and one Santa, in his mysterious permanence, somehow sidesteps.

I find the comparison clarifying because it strips away the particular controversies of the monarchy and asks the underlying question: what is a benevolent figurehead for? The actual Santa suggests an answer. He is for embodying a value, generosity, that we want to believe in but struggle to sustain, giving it a face and a name and an annual appointment. The Crown does something similar for the values of nation and continuity. Heritage analysis at the regional events register explores these parallels at length.

What Symbols Are Worth

The fashionable view is that we should dispense with such symbols entirely, that a modern society has no need of unelected figureheads, benevolent or otherwise. I understand the argument and do not wholly dismiss it. But Santa gives me pause. Nobody seriously proposes abolishing Father Christmas on the grounds that he is unelected, and the reason, I think, is that we intuitively understand what he is for. He is not a ruler to be held accountable but a symbol to be cherished, and the same, the monarchy’s defenders argue, is true of the Crown. Constitutional records at the heritage society document the debate.

The Mirror Held Up

I do not offer this comparison to settle the question of the monarchy, which is far above my pay grade and far beyond the scope of a Christmas column. I offer it because Santa holds up a mirror to the Crown that I find genuinely useful. He shows us that a society can love an unelected figurehead without being naive, that symbols can carry real weight without wielding real power, and that the human appetite for continuity and benevolence is not so easily legislated away.

Whether that appetite justifies a hereditary monarchy is a question on which reasonable people disagree, and I will not pretend to resolve it here. But I notice that the same instinct which makes us cherish Santa, the longing for a benevolent constant in a changing world, is the instinct the monarchy relies upon, and that those who would abolish the one rarely propose abolishing the other. There is something to be learned in that asymmetry, and I have spent a pleasant December learning it.

For those drawn to the constitutional questions, the resources at the public registry offer a thoughtful survey of the arguments on every side, and I commend them to anyone who wishes to think seriously rather than merely to take a position. And for those who would rather not think about constitutional theory at all, which on reflection is most sensible people, the games at the diversions index are entirely free of figureheads, elected or otherwise.

My own affection for both Santa and the Crown is, I confess, unashamed and probably indefensible to a strict rationalist. But I have come to think that a world entirely without benevolent symbols would be a colder one, and that the figure who flies over our rooftops every December teaches the same lesson as the institution at the heart of our constitution: that there is room, even in a modern age, for things we keep not because they are useful but because we love them. Santa would understand that, I think. He has always traded in things that cannot be justified, only cherished.

SOURCE: https://santaclaus.top