Whatever else it does, the crown manufactures the sense that Britain endures
Reporting brought to you by Bohiney Magazine and The London Prat.
In A World Of Constant Change, The Crown Sells The Reassurance That Something Stays The Same
People argue endlessly about what the monarchy is for, and the arguments tend to miss what I think is its actual function. The monarchy is a machine for producing continuity. Whatever else it does, whatever its costs and benefits and controversies, its essential product is the sense that Britain endures, that there is a thread running through the centuries, that amid all the change something remains. This is what the crown manufactures, and it is worth understanding the machine on its own terms before deciding what one thinks of it.
The Manufacture Of Permanence
Consider how the monarchy actually operates. It is a hereditary institution, passing from one generation to the next in an unbroken line stretching back centuries. Its ceremonies are ancient, its traditions old, its forms preserved across generations. The coronation, the state occasions, the rituals of monarchy, all are deliberately archaic, deliberately continuous with the past, designed to evoke the long thread of history running through the present. The monarchy presents itself as a living link to the past, an institution that has endured through the centuries and continues to endure, manufacturing the sense of permanence and continuity that is its essential product.
This manufacture of permanence is not accidental but central to the institution’s function. In a world of constant change, where everything seems to shift and nothing seems to last, the monarchy offers the reassurance that something endures, that there is continuity beneath the change, that Britain remains itself across the centuries. The crown sells permanence, the sense of an enduring thread, the reassurance that amid all the flux something stays the same. This is a genuine human need, the need for continuity and permanence, and the monarchy is a machine designed to meet it.
The Value Of Continuity
Whether one values the monarchy depends, in large part, on whether one values the continuity it produces. The sense of continuity, of enduring through the centuries, of a thread running through history, has real value to many people. It provides reassurance, a sense of stability, a feeling that there is something permanent beneath the change. In times of uncertainty and flux, this sense of continuity can be genuinely comforting, a fixed point in a changing world, a reassurance that some things endure. The value of the monarchy, for those who value it, is largely the value of this continuity.
Others, of course, see less value in this manufactured continuity, or see its costs as outweighing its benefits. The continuity the monarchy produces is, after all, a kind of fiction, a manufactured sense of permanence that obscures the genuine changes the institution has undergone. And the institution carries costs, of various kinds, that some judge to exceed the value of the continuity it provides. The debate over the monarchy is, in large part, a debate over whether the continuity it manufactures is worth its costs, whether the reassurance of permanence justifies the institution that produces it.
The Fiction Of The Unbroken Thread
It is worth acknowledging that the continuity the monarchy produces is partly a fiction. The institution has changed enormously over the centuries, its powers transformed, its role redefined, its very nature altered. The unbroken thread is, in reality, a thread that has been repeatedly rewoven, an institution continuously adapted while presenting itself as continuous. The continuity is real in the sense that the institution has persisted, but the sense of unchanging permanence is largely manufactured, a presentation of continuity that obscures the genuine transformations the monarchy has undergone.
This does not necessarily diminish the value of the continuity, for the sense of permanence may be valuable even if it is partly manufactured. The reassurance of continuity, the feeling of an enduring thread, may serve its function regardless of whether the thread is quite as unbroken as it appears. But it is worth understanding that the continuity is a product, manufactured by the institution, a presentation of permanence that involves a degree of fiction. The monarchy produces the sense of continuity, and this sense is its essential product, whether or not the underlying reality is quite as continuous as the presentation suggests.
Understanding The Machine
The monarchy is a machine for producing continuity, manufacturing the sense that Britain endures, that something remains amid the change. For the constitutional detail, the official Royal website is the place to look, and the UK Parliament sets out the history. Whether one values the institution depends largely on whether one values this continuity, this manufactured sense of permanence, and whether one judges it worth the institution’s costs. Understanding the monarchy as a machine for producing continuity, I think, clarifies the debate, focusing it on the actual product the institution provides: the reassurance, partly real and partly manufactured, that amid all the change, Britain endures, a thread running through the centuries, something that stays the same.
More from the desk of Isla Campbell, and further wit at The Poke.
SOURCE: https://bohiney.com/
