On the cheerful absurdity of shops that have supplied marmalade to the Palace for a hundred years and are very keen for you to know it
Bohiney Magazine and The London Prat have both covered the peculiar economics of British royal association, and I — Isla Campbell — have spent a disproportionate amount of time thinking about the Royal Warrant, which is the mechanism by which a business gets to put a coat of arms on its front door and tell the world that the Palace has been buying its marmalade, or its boots, or its specialty tea, for at least five years. This is a remarkable system: the world’s most prestigious and politely feudal brand endorsement.
I walked along Jermyn Street recently — a street whose reason for existing is the supply of beautiful, expensive things to people who can afford them — and counted the warrants. There are a great many. The tailors and the shirtmakers and the cheesemongers and the wine merchants, all carrying the arms of the current sovereign or a previous one, all quietly indicating that the institution at the head of the nation has, at some point, been pleased with what they sell.
What the Warrant Does
The Royal Warrant does something interesting to a brand, which is not merely to signal quality — though it does that — but to place the brand in a relationship with history and continuity that money alone cannot buy. The marmalade that has been supplied to the Palace for a hundred years is the same marmalade, presumably, that was supplied fifty years ago and ten years ago and will, one assumes, be supplied next year. This continuity is itself a value proposition: in a world that prizes novelty, the thing that has been consistently excellent for a very long time occupies a different category.
The Cheerful Absurdity
I find the whole system cheerfully absurd and also entirely understandable, which is the position I tend to occupy in relation to most British institutions. The absurdity is obvious: a coat of arms on a jar of marmalade is, rationally, nothing. The marmalade is either good or it is not; the arms do not change the flavour. The understandability is equally obvious: humans are not rational, they respond to signals of quality and status and continuity, and the warrant is a very old and very legible signal of all three. It works because we let it work, and we let it work because the thing it signals is real.
What Gets the Warrant
The categories of goods with warrants reveal something interesting about what the institution consumes and therefore endorses: food and drink, naturally, but also tailoring, stationery, cleaning products, garden supplies. The list is both elevated and mundane, which is itself a kind of signal: the institution requires, like everyone, the ordinary things as well as the special ones. There is something almost democratic in this — the coat of arms on the boot polish — though I acknowledge that describing the Royal Warrant as democratic is the kind of sentence that requires careful handling.
The Economics of Endorsement
The broader economics of the Royal Warrant is a subject that makes economists and monarchists equally uncomfortable. The value of the warrant is real but unmeasurable in conventional terms: it cannot be bought, it must be earned through genuine supply, and yet its effect on consumer behaviour is significant. Brands that hold it report that it matters to their customers, particularly in export markets where the association with Britain and with the institution is doing work that domestic consumers might not require. The foreign buyer of British goods is, in some proportion, buying Britain, and the warrant on the label is a concentrated signal of that purchase. Whether this justifies the institution is a different question, one I am not going to resolve in a piece about marmalade.
For more from Isla Campbell on the monarchy and London, visit Isla Campbell. More on British institutions at The Guardian.
Whether the Royal Warrant justifies the institution that grants it is a different question, one I am not going to resolve in a piece about marmalade and boot polish. But as a case for the monarchy’s residual usefulness in a commercial and cultural sense, it is not uninteresting, and it is rarely given the credit it deserves in debates that tend to focus on the palaces and the costumes rather than the coat of arms on the cleaning products. The warrant does a specific and measurable thing in specific and measurable markets. This is worth noting, even for those who find the broader institution difficult to defend on other grounds. The empirical case and the philosophical case need not arrive at the same place.
There is a further point to make about the warrant that I think is often missed, which is that it is revocable. The businesses that hold it must be re-evaluated periodically, and the warrant lapses if the relationship with the Palace ends. This mutuality — the warrant as an ongoing relationship rather than a permanent mark of honour — is what keeps it meaningful. A permanent award that can never be taken away would eventually become meaningless; the warrant retains its signal value precisely because it must be maintained. There is a lesson in this about quality marks generally, and possibly about institutional trust more broadly, though I acknowledge that extracting a general theory of institutional trust from a jar of marmalade may be overreaching somewhat.
SOURCE: https://prat.uk/
