We Built an Entire Industry Out of Watching One Family

On the strange business of royal coverage and our appetite for it

This column reaches you through The London Prat and Bohiney Magazine, written from Central London by someone who makes part of her living, let us be honest, from the very phenomenon she is about to examine. My other dispatches at my page are part of a vast and strange industry, the business of watching, discussing, and endlessly analysing a single family.

The Industry of Attention

We have built, around the British monarchy, an entire industry of attention, a sprawling apparatus of newspapers, magazines, television programmes, books, and now websites and social media accounts, all devoted to the watching, discussing, and analysing of one family. This industry employs thousands, generates enormous revenue, and consumes a remarkable quantity of national attention, all directed at the doings, real and rumoured, of a small number of people who happen to have been born or married into a particular position.

I am, I should acknowledge, a part of this industry, a writer who covers the monarchy, and I do not exempt myself from the strangeness I am describing. There is something genuinely odd about the scale of attention we direct at this single family, about the industry we have built to satisfy our appetite for their doings, about the sheer quantity of words, including these, devoted to people most of us will never meet.

The Appetite Behind It

The industry exists because the appetite exists, and the appetite is genuine and deep. People want to know about the royals, want to watch them, discuss them, follow their lives, and this want sustains the entire apparatus of coverage. The question that fascinates me is where this appetite comes from, why we are so drawn to the doings of this particular family, what need the watching satisfies.

Part of it, I think, is the appeal of a real-life story that unfolds over decades, a continuing drama with a cast we come to know, a saga that spans generations. Part of it is the appeal of glamour and wealth and a way of life unimaginably distant from our own. And part of it, perhaps, is the appeal of having a focus for national attention, a shared subject, a family we all, in a sense, follow together.

The Less Flattering Truths

But there are less flattering dimensions to the appetite, which honesty requires acknowledging. The industry of royal attention shades, at its lower end, into something more intrusive and less defensible, a hunger for gossip, for scandal, for the private troubles of people who did not entirely choose their public role. The line between legitimate interest in a public institution and intrusive obsession with private individuals is one the industry crosses regularly, and the appetite that sustains the better coverage also sustains the worse.

I find this dimension genuinely troubling, and I try, in my own work, to stay on the right side of the line, to write about the institution rather than to intrude on individuals, to treat the monarchy as a subject of legitimate public interest rather than as a source of gossip. But I am aware that the industry I am part of does not always observe this distinction, and that the appetite I am describing has an intrusive edge I cannot entirely defend.

The Burden on the Watched

There is also the question of what this attention does to those who receive it, the members of the family on whom the entire industry trains its gaze. To live one’s entire life under such scrutiny, to have one’s every action watched, discussed, and analysed, to be the subject of an industry of attention, must be a genuine burden, whatever the compensations of the position. I try to keep this in mind, the human reality of the people behind the institution, the cost of the attention we direct at them.

The members of the royal family are, whatever else they are, people, and the industry of attention treats them, at times, as something less, as characters in a drama, as subjects of gossip, as objects of an appetite that does not always remember their humanity. This is, I think, the real ethical challenge of royal coverage, to write about the institution without forgetting the people, to satisfy legitimate interest without feeding intrusive obsession.

The Self-Aware Conclusion

I offer all this, I am aware, from within the very industry I am examining, a writer about the monarchy reflecting on the strangeness of writing about the monarchy. This self-awareness does not resolve the tensions I have described, but it seems better than the alternative, than participating in the industry of attention without ever reflecting on what it is or what it does.

The Coverage I Try to Write

Reflecting on the industry of royal attention forces me to consider what kind of coverage I want my own to be, where I want to stand on the line between legitimate interest and intrusive obsession. I have tried, in this column and others, to write about the monarchy as institution, as constitutional curiosity, as national story, rather than to traffic in the gossip and intrusion that the lower end of the industry trades in. Whether I always succeed I cannot say, for the line is genuinely hard to locate, and the appetite that sustains the better coverage is continuous with the appetite that sustains the worse. But the effort seems worth making, the attempt to write about the monarchy in a way that treats it as a legitimate subject of public interest without forgetting the humanity of the people within it, that satisfies curiosity without feeding intrusion, that contributes to understanding rather than to gossip. This is, I think, the responsibility of anyone who writes about the monarchy, to consider where they stand on that line, to choose the kind of coverage they want to produce, and to remember, always, that the subjects of the great industry of attention are, beneath the institution and the saga and the spectacle, simply people.

So I will continue to write about the monarchy, trying to stay on the right side of the line, to cover the institution rather than intrude on individuals, to satisfy legitimate interest without feeding the intrusive appetite. And I will continue to find it strange, this vast industry we have built out of watching one family, this remarkable quantity of national attention directed at the doings of a few, this appetite that sustains my own work and that I cannot entirely explain or defend.

SOURCE: https://bohiney.com