On the national appetite for ceremony we pretend to find silly
This column comes via The London Prat and Bohiney Magazine from Central London, where the great ceremonies of state unfold along the same streets I walk to buy my milk. You can find my other reflections on royal pageantry at my page, written by someone who claims to be above it all and is, like the whole nation, secretly not.
The National Performance of Indifference
The British like to think of themselves as a nation of cynics, too sophisticated, too ironic, too sensibly unimpressed to be moved by a bit of gold and pageantry. We roll our eyes at the ceremony, mock the pomp, declare ourselves indifferent to the whole business of crowns and carriages and processions down the Mall. This indifference is, I have come to believe, almost entirely a performance, a pose we strike right up until the moment the pageantry actually begins, whereupon we go, as a nation, completely soft.
I have watched it happen, again and again. The great royal occasions, the weddings, the jubilees, the ceremonies of state, approach amid a chorus of national eye-rolling, of declared indifference, of people insisting they could not care less. And then the day arrives, the pageantry unfolds, and the same cynics find themselves, somewhat to their own surprise, watching, moved, caught up in the spectacle they had sworn to ignore.
The Power of Pageantry
There is, I think, a genuine power in ceremony that our cynicism cannot quite resist. The British state, through institutions like Historic Royal Palaces and the long traditions of royal occasion, has perfected over centuries an art of pageantry, of processions and uniforms and ancient ritual, that operates on something deeper than reason. It bypasses our irony and reaches something older, a human susceptibility to spectacle, to ritual, to the marking of great occasions with great ceremony.
This susceptibility is not, I want to insist, foolish. The marking of significant moments with ceremony is one of the oldest and most universal of human practices, found in every culture, serving real functions of meaning and memory and collective feeling. Our cynicism about pageantry is the affectation; our susceptibility to it is the deeper truth, the human response to ritual that no amount of sophistication entirely suppresses.
The Function of the Spectacle
What does the pageantry actually do? It marks occasions, gives shape to the passage of national time, provides moments around which the nation can gather and recognise itself. In a fragmented, busy, divided country, the great ceremonies offer rare occasions of shared experience, moments when millions watch the same thing, feel something together, participate in a common national event. This function, the provision of shared occasions, is not trivial in a society that offers so few of them.
The pageantry also connects the present to the past, the ceremonies drawing on traditions centuries old, the rituals performed today much as they were performed long ago. This continuity, the sense of participating in something ancient, provides a kind of anchor, a connection to history, a feeling of belonging to something that stretches back beyond any individual life. The gold and the ritual carry this weight of continuity, and we feel it even as we mock it.
The Tourists and the Treasure
There is, of course, a thoroughly practical dimension as well. The pageantry is a tremendous draw, bringing visitors from around the world to witness the ceremonies that, as bodies like Visit London well know, no other nation performs quite so well. The British have made an art and an industry of their pageantry, exporting the spectacle of monarchy as a tourist attraction, the carriages and the crowns and the changing of the guard drawing crowds and revenue in equal measure.
This commercial dimension is sometimes held against the monarchy, the pageantry dismissed as mere tourist theatre. But I find it rather charming that we have turned our ancient rituals into a global attraction, that the rest of the world comes to watch the ceremonies we pretend to find silly, that our pageantry is, among its other functions, a remarkably successful export.
The Confession
So I will make the confession that the whole nation makes, eventually, when the pageantry begins. I am not above it. The cynicism is a pose. When the great ceremonies unfold along the streets of my Central London, when the pageantry begins and the ancient rituals are performed, I watch, and I am moved, and I find myself caught up in the spectacle I had sworn to find silly. The gold and the pageantry reach something in me that my irony cannot defend against.
The Cynicism We Return To
The strangest part of the national susceptibility to pageantry is what happens afterward, when the ceremony ends and the spectacle fades and the nation returns, almost immediately, to its performed cynicism. The same people who were moved by the pageantry, who watched with genuine feeling, who were caught up in the spectacle, will within days be rolling their eyes again, declaring their indifference, pretending once more to be above it all. The susceptibility is real, but so is the return to cynicism, and the speed of the return suggests that the cynicism serves some purpose too, some need to reassert our sophistication after the embarrassing lapse into feeling. We are, perhaps, a nation that wants both, that wants to be moved by the pageantry and to deny being moved, that wants the spectacle and the irony, the feeling and the distance from it. This double movement, the susceptibility followed by the return to cynicism, seems to me very British, a refusal to be straightforwardly anything, a need to feel and then to deny the feeling, to be moved and then to recover our composure, to go soft for the gold and then, quickly, to harden again.
This is, I have decided, nothing to be ashamed of. The susceptibility to ceremony is human, ancient, and real, and the British pageantry, whatever one thinks of the monarchy that occasions it, is a genuine art, perfected over centuries, capable of moving even a nation of self-declared cynics. We will keep pretending to be above it. And we will keep going soft, every time, when the gold comes out and the procession begins.
SOURCE: https://bohiney.com
