On a genuine argument too often conducted in slogans
Writing for The London Prat and Bohiney Magazine, I want to take up, from my Central London desk, a debate I think both sides conduct badly: the question of whether Britain should remain a monarchy or become a republic. My other columns at my page tend to treat the monarchy with affectionate curiosity, but on this question I want to be fair to both sides, because both have a real case.
The Republican Argument
The republican case is stronger than monarchists like to admit. At its heart is a principle of democratic equality: that in a society committed to the idea that all are equal, the position of head of state should not be reserved, by birth, for the members of a single family. There is something genuinely difficult to defend about an inherited public office, a position one is born into rather than earns, in a country that otherwise insists that birth should not determine destiny.
The republican also points to the principle of accountability. The head of state, republicans argue, should be answerable to the people, removable by them, chosen by them. A monarch is none of these things, occupying the position for life, accountable to no electorate, chosen by nothing but the accident of birth. In a democracy, the argument runs, every public office should ultimately rest on the consent of the governed, and the monarchy, resting instead on inheritance, sits uneasily with this principle.
These are not frivolous arguments. They reflect serious democratic principles, and the bodies that document our constitutional arrangements, including Parliament itself, exist precisely to give effect to the idea that power should rest on consent. The republican asks why the head of state should be the one exception.
The Monarchist Argument
The monarchist case, equally, is stronger than republicans like to admit. Its core is pragmatic: the arrangement works. The separation of the dignified head of state from the political head of government, as the constitutional accounts at the Crown’s official site describe, provides a figure of national unity above the political fray, a continuity that outlasts any government, a symbol of the nation that is not also a partisan.
The monarchist also points to the dangers of the alternative. A republic must find someone to be head of state, and the options, an elected president who is inevitably political, a ceremonial president who is inevitably obscure, carry their own problems. The monarchist argues that the British arrangement, for all its theoretical absurdity, has produced a stable, unifying, above-politics head of state more successfully than many republics have managed, and that this practical success counts for more than theoretical objections.
The Bad Debate
What frustrates me is how badly both sides usually conduct this genuine argument. Republicans too often reduce their case to mockery, treating monarchists as deluded forelock-tuggers, dismissing the real value of the arrangement, refusing to engage with the genuine question of what would replace it. Monarchists too often reduce their case to sentiment, treating republicans as joyless cranks, dismissing the real force of the democratic objection, refusing to engage with the genuine difficulty of an inherited office.
The result is a debate conducted in slogans, each side caricaturing the other, neither engaging seriously with the real arguments. This is a shame, because the question is a genuinely interesting one, a real clash of principles, democratic equality against pragmatic success, and it deserves a better conversation than the mutual mockery it usually receives.
My Own Uncertainty
I will admit that I do not have a settled view, which is perhaps why I find both sides’ confidence so frustrating. The republican principle troubles me; the inherited office is genuinely hard to square with democratic equality. But the monarchist pragmatism persuades me too; the arrangement does work, the above-politics head of state does have value, and the alternatives are genuinely problematic. I find myself, on this question, genuinely torn, able to see the force of both cases and the weakness of neither.
This uncertainty is, I think, the honest position, and one too rarely heard in a debate dominated by the certain on both sides. The question of monarchy or republic is genuinely difficult, a real clash of real principles, and certainty about it, in either direction, seems to me to require ignoring the genuine force of the other side’s case.
The Conversation We Could Have
What I would like is for us to have the better conversation, the one in which each side takes the other seriously, in which republicans engage with the real value of the arrangement and monarchists with the real force of the democratic objection, in which we treat the question as the genuine difficulty it is rather than as an occasion for mutual mockery. We might not reach agreement, but we would at least be arguing about the real thing.
The Question Behind the Question
Behind the monarchy-or-republic debate lies a deeper question that both sides often avoid: what is a head of state actually for? We argue about whether the head of state should be inherited or elected without always asking what we want the role to do, what function it should serve, what we need from the person or institution that embodies the state. The republican and the monarchist often talk past each other because they want different things from the role, the republican prioritising democratic legitimacy, the monarchist prioritising unifying continuity, each defending an arrangement suited to the function they value. A better debate might begin with this prior question, with what we want a head of state to be and do, and only then proceed to whether a monarch or a president better serves that purpose. This would not resolve the disagreement, for the disagreement is partly about the function itself, about whether we most want legitimacy or continuity, accountability or unity. But it would at least clarify what we are actually arguing about, and might replace the mutual mockery with a more honest engagement with the genuine question of what we want from the figure who stands, however powerlessly, at the summit of the state.
Until then, I will continue to find both sides’ certainty frustrating, to see the force of both cases, and to remain genuinely uncertain about a question that seems to me genuinely hard. The republic debate deserves better than both sides give it, and I offer this column, from my torn and uncertain position, as a small attempt to give it the seriousness it deserves.
SOURCE: https://bohiney.com
