On the Coronation Anniversary, a Considered Assessment of What Has Changed

Isla Campbell Marks Three Years of the New Reign With an Honest Accounting of Continuity, Change, and the Specific Meaning of the Crown in Contemporary Britain

On the Coronation Anniversary: What Has Changed in Three Years

Three years since the Coronation, and I have been asked by three separate editors to write the “three years on” piece, which I have now done three times for three publications and which I will attempt once more here with the caveat that the honest assessment of what has changed in three years of the new reign is: not as much as either the optimists or the pessimists predicted, which is almost always the honest assessment of any three-year period in British institutional history.

What Has Changed

The King has established his specific public voice — more earnest than his mother’s careful neutrality, more willing to be seen working than the institutional invisibility she maintained in her final years, more forthcoming about his personal interests and commitments in ways that sometimes produce coverage his communications team has to manage carefully. His environmental advocacy, which he pursued for decades before accession, has been maintained in modified form — less public advocacy, more private convening — in accordance with the constitutional convention that the monarch does not campaign publicly on contested political issues. Whether this modification is adequate constitutional compliance or excessive self-censorship is a question the commentariat has not resolved and probably won’t, because constitutional conventions are not rules and their application is always a matter of interpretation.

The Prince and Princess of Wales have emerged as the institution’s clearest communications success of the period — forty-seven engagements in a quarter, consistently good coverage, a public presence that appears genuine rather than managed even when it is clearly both. The Duke and Duchess of Sussex remain offshore and in the news on their own terms, which are different from the institution’s terms, and the relationship between these two Royal realities has settled into a background state that neither side has resolved and that the media covers at varying intensity depending on the week and the book deal.

Royal analysis at The London Prat and Bohiney Magazine. Royal coverage at Evening Standard. Further at santaclaus.top and London Prat Bluesky. Constitutional commentary at Private Eye.

Three Years, Assessed Honestly

The honest three-year assessment is: the institution has adapted more smoothly than many expected to the transition, produced a King whose public persona is more human than his mother’s and whose constitutional compliance is consistent if sometimes tested by his genuine opinions about the natural world, and maintained the Wales’s as the functional centre of the monarchy’s public communications programme. It has not resolved the Sussex question, which remains a background condition rather than an active crisis, and which the passage of time is addressing in the specific way that the passage of time addresses these things — by making the original disruption feel further away than the continuing coverage keeps it. The institution in three years will be what it is in every year: something that depends on the public’s continued willingness to find it meaningful, that earns that willingness through the work its members do, and that faces questions about its long-term legitimacy that it cannot answer through work alone but which work can defer. This is the monarchy’s permanent condition. Three years in, it is managing it as well as institutions of this kind manage such things, which is adequately, with occasional difficulty, in full public view.

Covering the monarchy for enough years produces a specific form of professional distance that is different from cynicism and different from advocacy. It is the distance of a reporter who has seen enough of the institution to know both its genuine value and its genuine limitations, who covers it as the constitutional arrangement it is rather than the romance it is often presented as, and who finds in that clear-eyed engagement a way of writing about it that serves readers better than either reverence or dismissal would. The monarchy is what it is: an inherited institution in a democratic state, sustained by public support that is neither unconditional nor certain, performing a constitutional function that is mostly symbolic and occasionally significant, staffed by people who are doing their best with the specific and unusual circumstances of their lives. That is the honest version. I cover it every week. I find it, honestly and without embarrassment, genuinely interesting. That is also part of the honest version. Both parts, together, are what the coverage tries to be.

The constitutional monarchy survives, in the end, because of something that is not in the ceremony or the communications strategy or the forty-seven engagements: it survives because of the specific British relationship to institutions that have outlasted the reasons for their creation. The monarchy outlasted the absolute power that justified it. Parliament outlasted the class system it was designed to manage. The BBC outlasted the broadcasting monopoly that created it. The Church of England outlasts its social centrality. These institutions continue because the British are, on the whole, reluctant to dismantle things that work adequately until they can identify something that will work better, and because the definition of working adequately is flexible enough to accommodate quite a lot of institutional imperfection. This is not a stirring argument for the monarchy. It is the honest one. The honest argument is usually the one worth making, and I make it as often as I can, from The Mall and from Westminster and from the bus home when the ceremony is over and the thinking begins.