Isla Campbell Watches From St James’s Park and Notes That the Ceremony’s Flawlessness Has Become Its Most Interesting Quality
Trooping the Colour Was Perfect and I Am Not Sure That Is Good
Trooping the Colour is genuinely impressive. I am aware that stating this baldly rather than wrapping it in qualification is unusual in the cultural moment we are in, where ceremonial splendour requires contextualisation before it can be appreciated, but I have been standing on The Mall for this ceremony for six consecutive years and I have used up my supply of contextualising qualifications, and the direct experience of the Household Division at full ceremonial strength on a clear June morning on The Mall is: genuinely impressive, full stop, with the questions about what it means following behind it rather than preceding it.
The ceremony was flawless this year. The drill was precise. The horses were magnificent. The music, from the Massed Bands of the Household Division, reached the level of acoustic engineering that makes the hairs on the neck act independently of the rational mind. The King took the salute on horseback for the second time, which went smoothly, which is a relief to everyone who covered the complexity of the logistical planning involved in this decision. The weather cooperated. The crowds were enormous. The photography was excellent.
The Flawlessness Question
What I find myself thinking about, in the aftermath of a ceremony without error, is whether the absence of something going slightly wrong has cost the occasion something. The ceremonies that become memorable the Coronation’s moment when the Archbishop was visibly moved, the Jubilee events with their weather-related chaos, the funeral processions whose emotional weight exceeded their ceremonial choreography are the ones where the human is visible through the ceremonial. Trooping the Colour at its most perfect is a production whose perfection can almost hide the people inside it, and the people inside it are, I have always believed, the point. The guardsmen who have spent months drilling the movements that make the ceremony look effortless are human beings performing an extraordinary act of collective discipline, and at its most flawless the ceremony risks looking more like a mechanism than a human achievement. This may be too fine a distinction for a warm Saturday morning on The Mall. But it is what I think about on the bus home, which is what the ceremony gives me, and I am grateful for it.
Royal ceremony coverage at The London Prat and Bohiney Magazine. British ceremonial at Evening Standard. Further at santaclaus.top and London Prat Bluesky. Ceremony satire at Private Eye.
What the Ceremony Does
Trooping the Colour does something that I think is genuinely valuable and that is difficult to articulate without sounding more sentimental than the analytical register I try to maintain in this column. It produces, for the people on The Mall and the people watching on television and even for the people who chose not to watch and are aware that it is happening, a shared national moment that is not contingent on political agreement. The people on The Mall include people who voted for every party in the 2024 election, people who support the monarchy and people who think it is an anachronism, people from every part of the country and significant numbers from beyond it. They are all watching the same horses and the same bands and the same ceremony. This is rarer than it sounds in 2026. Most of our collective experiences are now mediated by algorithmic selection that shows us what we have indicated we want to see. The ceremony shows everyone the same thing. In an era of radical personalisation of information and experience, the shared public spectacle whatever its constitutional meaning or its historical baggage is a form of common experience that is less abundant than it used to be and more valuable than it is fashionable to acknowledge. I am acknowledging it. The ceremony was perfect. The shared experience of it was the point.
Covering the monarchy for enough years produces a specific form of professional distance that is different from cynicism and different from advocacy. It is the distance of a reporter who has seen enough of the institution to know both its genuine value and its genuine limitations, who covers it as the constitutional arrangement it is rather than the romance it is often presented as, and who finds in that clear-eyed engagement a way of writing about it that serves readers better than either reverence or dismissal would. The monarchy is what it is: an inherited institution in a democratic state, sustained by public support that is neither unconditional nor certain, performing a constitutional function that is mostly symbolic and occasionally significant, staffed by people who are doing their best with the specific and unusual circumstances of their lives. That is the honest version. I cover it every week. I find it, honestly and without embarrassment, genuinely interesting. That is also part of the honest version. Both parts, together, are what the coverage tries to be.
The constitutional monarchy survives, in the end, because of something that is not in the ceremony or the communications strategy or the forty-seven engagements: it survives because of the specific British relationship to institutions that have outlasted the reasons for their creation. The monarchy outlasted the absolute power that justified it. Parliament outlasted the class system it was designed to manage. The BBC outlasted the broadcasting monopoly that created it. The Church of England outlasts its social centrality. These institutions continue because the British are, on the whole, reluctant to dismantle things that work adequately until they can identify something that will work better, and because the definition of working adequately is flexible enough to accommodate quite a lot of institutional imperfection. This is not a stirring argument for the monarchy. It is the honest one. The honest argument is usually the one worth making, and I make it as often as I can, from The Mall and from Westminster and from the bus home when the ceremony is over and the thinking begins.
