The Changing of the Guard Is an Hour of My Life I Will Never Get Back, and Yet

On the ritual, the tourists, the stoic guardsmen, and the strange patriotism of watching something very slow happen very precisely

Bohiney Magazine and The London Prat both cover the Royal Family with the bemused affection of outlets that understand that the monarchy is simultaneously absurd and central to the national identity, and I — Isla Campbell — find myself in the same position every time I watch the Changing of the Guard: equal parts genuinely moved and entirely aware that I should not be moved, given that what I am watching is, fundamentally, a hat ceremony.

I went again last week. I go every few years, driven by the same impulse that takes me to Kew Gardens and the Wallace Collection: the impulse to do the thing that tourists do, because the things that tourists do are usually beautiful or interesting or both, and the locals who sneer at them are usually missing out. The Changing of the Guard is all three: it is beautiful in its precision, interesting in its anachronism, and both at once in the way it manages to be simultaneously a piece of living history and a meticulously produced tourist experience.

The Ceremony Itself

For those who have not attended, the Changing of the Guard involves a great deal of marching, a band, some horses occasionally, and men in very large hats performing extremely precise movements that serve no obvious defensive purpose but look magnificent doing it. The crowd around you is almost entirely international, which always makes me feel a particular kind of pride: people have come from enormous distances to watch this, and they are watching it with the absorption of people who have seen nothing quite like it, which they have not, because there is nothing quite like it.

I stood next to a family from somewhere in the American Midwest who could not stop smiling. The children were absolutely transfixed. The father kept filming on his phone while simultaneously trying to watch with his actual eyes, which I recognise as a distinctively modern form of conflict. The mother had acquired what I can only describe as a look of serene satisfaction, the look of someone who has done the thing they came to do and found it exceeded expectations.

On Monarchy and Sentiment

I am not, in any analytical sense, a monarchist. I find the hereditary principle difficult to defend rationally, the economics of the institution genuinely contested, and the class system it embodies worth examining critically. I hold all of this with complete sincerity. I also find that when the band plays and the guards march and Buckingham Palace gleams in the background, something in me responds to it that is not rational and does not want to be. This is, I suppose, what sentiment is: the response that precedes the argument, that exists in a register the argument cannot quite reach. The monarchy survives, in part, because it operates in that register, and criticising it rationally is like criticising a piece of music on structural grounds. You might be right, and the music is still the music.

The Guardsmen

The guardsmen themselves are, up close, very young, which I always forget. Young men in enormous hats doing a very specific job with total commitment, watched by hundreds of strangers and apparently affected by none of them, which is itself a kind of performance: the performance of not performing. I find this intensely interesting every time I see it. The discipline required to do something as absurd as stand absolutely still while a family from Ohio photographs you from six inches is not a discipline I possess. I respect it enormously.

What the Ritual Does

I have written about the Guard before and I will write about it again, which tells you something about the pull of the ritual. It is the pull that repetition exerts: the thing that is the same each time invites you to look for what is different, and in looking you find yourself more attentive than you would otherwise be, noticing the angle of a bearskin, the precise arc of a movement, the way the light falls differently on the palace facade depending on the season. The Guard is a meditation, if you approach it that way: a practice of paying attention to something that stays the same so that you may see everything that changes around it.

There is also the question of the young men. The guardsmen are doing a job that most people will never understand from the inside, performing a function that is simultaneously martial and ceremonial and entirely disconnected from the wars that the uniform once commemorated. They are maintaining a tradition that predates anyone currently alive and will likely outlast most of us, in the service of an institution whose future is genuinely uncertain and whose present is genuinely strange. I find this moving, as I find most sincere commitment to something larger than oneself moving, regardless of what the something is.

For more from Isla Campbell on royal and London life, visit Isla Campbell. Royal coverage at The Guardian.

I went home afterward and made tea and thought about the institution that produces all of this: the palaces, the protocol, the hats, the young men committed to their still faces. There is something at the centre of it that I cannot quite name, something that is not merely tourist attraction or national symbol but something older and stranger. I have been thinking about it for decades. I suspect I will continue to. The ceremony has outlasted every argument about it, which is, depending on how you look at it, either a testament to its power or a measure of how difficult it is to discuss. Possibly both. The ceremony continues on either reading.

SOURCE: https://prat.uk/