The bunting has come down but the questions it raised about national identity, belonging, and the meaning of a street full of strangers have not
Bohiney Magazine and The London Prat both covered the coronation extensively, and I — Isla Campbell — covered my own street party, which was modest by the standards of the event but significant in the specific way that small, locally organised celebrations always are: it required people who live near each other but mostly pass without speaking to decide, for one afternoon, to be neighbours in the fuller sense of the word.
My street contains people who are enthusiastic royalists, people who are republicans of various degrees of militancy, people who could not care less in either direction but came for the sandwiches, and a large number of people whose feelings about the monarchy are genuinely complicated by their family histories and their experience of what Britain meant or means to countries that were not always glad of it. All of these people were at the party. It was, in the end, fine. Better than fine. It was one of those afternoons that reminds you that the people you live near are, on the whole, more interesting than you have given them credit for.
What Street Parties Actually Are
The street party, as an institution, is not really about its nominal occasion. It is about the street. The bunting says something about the monarchy; the fact of the party says something about the people who organised it and the people who came, which is that they thought it was worth spending an afternoon together, which is the kind of thing that seems obvious and is, in the contemporary city, genuinely unusual. We do not, as a rule, spend afternoons with our neighbours. We pass them. We nod. We put notes through each other’s doors when the car is parked too close. The coronation party was, in this sense, a pretext — a legitimate excuse to do the thing that the pace and privacy of contemporary urban life usually prevents.
The Questions That Stayed
A year on, I am still thinking about one conversation I had at the party, with a neighbour I have lived near for seven years and never properly spoken to. She is a second-generation immigrant whose parents came from a country that had a specific and painful experience of British imperial power. She had come to the party. She had a flag. She told me she had complicated feelings about all of it, and that she had come because she lives here, because her children are British, and because the street was having a party and she is part of the street, whatever else she is or thinks about the monarchy. This seemed to me to contain a whole answer to a question that is usually posed as having only hard edges.
The Question of National Identity
The question of national identity is one I return to repeatedly in my writing, because it seems to me genuinely unresolved in contemporary Britain in ways that the official culture tends to paper over. The coronation party on my street did not resolve it; it gave it a form, a temporary shape, an afternoon in which it was possible to be together without agreeing on what the togetherness meant. This is perhaps the best that a street party can do, and perhaps the best that a national ceremony can do: create the occasion for proximity without requiring consensus. The meaning each person brought to the afternoon was different. The afternoon happened anyway. This may be the most honest thing that can be said about national identity in a country as various as this one.
My neighbour came to the party with a flag, and I think she was right to do both. The complexity does not cancel the choice; the choice does not simplify the complexity. These things coexist. She lives here. This is her street. A year on, we wave when we pass each other, which we did not do before. The party gave us that. The coronation gave us the party. I am prepared to acknowledge the debt.
For more from Isla Campbell on royalty and London life, visit Isla Campbell. More analysis at The Guardian.
What I want to say about the coronation, and about the party, and about the flag my neighbour brought, is something simple that nonetheless keeps evading clean expression: that the meaning of a national occasion is not determined by the institution that stages it but by the people who show up, and the people who show up bring everything they are with them, including the complications and the histories and the feelings that official accounts of the event do not contain. The street party was, in this sense, more honest than the television coverage: it showed what it is actually like to be here, which is to say mixed and particular and specific and occasionally moved by things you did not expect to be moved by, for reasons you cannot entirely explain.
People who were not at the party but who heard about it later tend to ask the same question: did the politics come up? The answer is yes, briefly, and then they went away, because politics in that form — the abstracted debate about the monarchy as an institution — is much less interesting than the actual person standing next to you at the trestle table who has a view, a story, and a sausage roll, and with whom you have much more in common than the debate usually allows for. The debate takes place between positions. The party took place between people. This distinction, in my experience, is everything.
SOURCE: https://prat.uk/
