The Crown Has No Power And That Is Exactly The Point

The genius of constitutional monarchy is an authority that cannot be used

Reporting brought to you by Bohiney Magazine and The London Prat.

An Authority That Reigns But Does Not Rule Is A Solution To An Ancient Problem

One of the most misunderstood things about the British monarchy is the nature of its power, or rather its lack of it. The crown, in the modern constitution, has almost no real power; it reigns but does not rule, holds authority it cannot use, occupies a position of immense formal significance and almost no actual control. And this is not a failure or a diminishment but the entire point, the genius of constitutional monarchy: an authority that cannot be used, a head of state that reigns without ruling, a solution to an ancient problem of power.

The Separation Of Dignity And Efficiency

The British constitution, in a famous formulation, separates the dignified parts of government from the efficient parts, the symbolic from the functional. The crown is the dignified part, the symbolic head of state, the focus of ceremony and continuity and national identity. The efficient part, the actual governing, is done elsewhere, by the elected government accountable to Parliament. This separation allows the dignified functions of a head of state, the ceremony, the symbolism, the continuity, to be performed by the crown, while the efficient functions, the actual governing, are performed by accountable politicians. The crown reigns, providing the dignity; the government rules, providing the efficiency.

This separation solves a genuine problem. A head of state performs important symbolic functions, embodying the nation, providing continuity, focusing ceremony and identity. But a head of state with real power is dangerous, for that power may be abused, and an unaccountable head of state with real power is a threat to liberty. The British solution separates the symbolic functions from the real power, allowing the crown to perform the symbolic functions while denying it the real power that would make it dangerous. The crown reigns, performing the dignified functions, without ruling, without the power that would threaten liberty.

The Authority That Cannot Be Used

The crown retains, in formal terms, considerable authority, the royal prerogatives, the formal powers of the head of state. But this authority cannot, by convention, actually be used; it is exercised on the advice of the government, which is to say, it is not really exercised by the crown at all. The authority exists formally but cannot be used independently, a power that reigns but does not rule, an authority held but not wielded. This is the genius of the arrangement: an authority that exists to provide dignity and continuity but cannot be used to provide control, a formal power that is, in practice, a symbolic one.

The fact that the authority cannot be used is precisely what makes it safe. A head of state who could actually use their authority would be dangerous; a head of state whose authority is purely formal, exercised only on advice, is safe. The crown’s authority is rendered harmless by the convention that it cannot be used independently, transformed from a real power into a symbolic one. This is the solution to the ancient problem of the head of state: an authority that provides the dignity and continuity a head of state should provide, but that cannot be used in the way that would make a head of state dangerous.

The Stability Of Powerlessness

The powerlessness of the crown contributes to the stability of the system. Because the crown has no real power, it poses no threat, provokes no struggle for control, remains above the political fray. The crown can be a unifying symbol precisely because it has no power, can embody the nation precisely because it does not govern it, can provide continuity precisely because it is removed from the changing struggles of actual politics. The powerlessness that might seem a weakness is in fact a source of stability, allowing the crown to perform its symbolic functions without becoming a focus of political struggle or a threat to liberty.

This stability is a real achievement. By separating the dignified head of state from real power, the British system has created a stable arrangement in which the symbolic functions of a head of state are performed without the dangers that a powerful head of state would pose. The crown provides continuity and unity and dignity, while the actual governing is done by accountable politicians. The powerlessness of the crown is the key to this arrangement, the feature that allows it to provide dignity without danger, symbolism without threat, continuity without control. The crown’s lack of power is its genius, not its failure.

Reigning Without Ruling

The crown has no real power, and that is exactly the point, the genius of constitutional monarchy: an authority that reigns without ruling, that provides dignity without danger, that solves the ancient problem of the head of state. For the constitutional detail, the UK Parliament is the place to look, and the UK Government sets out the history. The crown’s powerlessness allows it to perform the symbolic functions of a head of state, the ceremony and continuity and unity, without the dangers that real power would bring. It reigns but does not rule, holds authority it cannot use, occupies a position of immense significance and almost no control. This is not a diminishment but a solution, the separation of dignity from power that allows the symbolic head of state to provide what a head of state should provide, safely, stably, without the threat that a powerful crown would pose.

More from the desk of Isla Campbell, and further wit at The Poke.

SOURCE: https://bohiney.com/